YouTube hides Subscriptions: a bet on watch time, not on you
Moving Subscriptions out of the bottom bar is sold as a smoother Home, but in our view it nudges viewers away from the channels they chose toward feeds YouTube picks.
AI-generated image
If a company wanted you to watch what it recommends instead of what you subscribed to, what would it do? Probably something very close to what YouTube just did: take the Subscriptions button off the spot your thumb already knows and give you a shiny new toy to play with instead.
Here is what happened. YouTube is removing the Subscriptions tab from the bottom bar of its Android and iPhone apps, where it had sat since 2017, as Ubergizmo reports. The feed is now called "Subs" and sits second in a row at the top of Home, after Home itself. The bottom bar shrinks to four items: Home, Shorts, Create and You. The slide-out menu is also gone.
The launch comes with custom feeds: you tap "+", describe what you want in plain language, and YouTube builds a feed around it. Free accounts can keep three and Premium members eight, according to iGeeksBlog.
Two steps instead of one is not a detail
The company frames this as the start of "a series of updates to shape a more seamless Home experience." We think "seamless" is doing a lot of work. Reaching Subs now means opening Home and then stretching to the top of the screen, which on a tall phone is the hardest place to reach with one hand. The same iGeeksBlog piece calls that "a step backward," and we agree.
Interface design is never neutral. The bottom bar is prime real estate: it holds what the app wants you to do by reflex. By taking Subscriptions out of it, YouTube changes the default behavior of everyone the redesign reaches without touching a single setting. Someone who opened the app to see the latest upload from five channels now lands on recommendations first, with their own choices one tab away. That is a small friction, but at YouTube's scale small frictions probably decide where attention goes.
The one feed that was only yours is now just another tab
What made Subscriptions special was that it was the only feed built exclusively on your decisions. No ranking guesswork about what might keep you around. Now it sits in a row next to Live, Music and feeds YouTube picks for you, and it is visually just one option among many.
The custom feeds deserve a fair hearing: letting people describe a mood or a topic is a genuinely useful idea, and the one example YouTube gave, short guided meditations after work, is exactly where a prompt beats a subscription list. But there is a catch. According to iGeeksBlog, videos watched in a custom feed count toward your regular watch history, so they can reshape your main Home feed as well. In other words, the "control" you get feeds the same recommendation engine. It looks like control, but it also generates more signals for the system.
YouTube wins, and viewers with a short list of channels lose
YouTube wins: more sessions starting from recommendation surfaces is, we suspect, good for watch time, though the company has not said that is the goal. Creators who depend on loyal subscribers probably lose a bit of direct access to their audience; that one is our prediction, not a measured outcome. And viewers with a short list of favorite channels lose a shortcut they used daily.
There is also a rollout problem. As Martin Cid reports, custom feeds work for now only in English for signed-in US users aged 13 or older with search history on, while YouTube gave no schedule or country list for the navigation change. Viewers elsewhere could lose the button long before they get the feature meant to compensate. The same piece notes that the top bar is not shown when watch history is paused, and YouTube does not spell out where those people find Subs.
Our advice: make Subs your first stop
Our verdict: this is a redesign that serves the platform more than the person holding the phone. If you rely on Subscriptions, don't wait for the update to surprise you. Rebuild the habit now: treat Subs as your real home screen and make a point of opening it first. Try a custom feed if you are curious, but remember that anything you watch there feeds your recommendations.
We would not bet on YouTube reversing course, but a "Subs first" option in settings is a modest request, and a fair one.
No topics yet: start the first one.
More stories
WhatsApp's Status U-turn proves that copying Snapchat isn't a strategy
Bringing back text Status after swapping it for a Snapchat-style feature shows that cloning a rival's format can't replace listening to how people actually use your app.
WhatsApp's View Once bug proves "disappearing" is a promise, not a guarantee
A bug let iPhone users reopen "View Once" photos by digging through storage settings. It's fixed, but the lesson is to treat ephemeral features as best effort, not protection.
WhatsApp is right to cut off old phones, but it owes users a real way out
Dropping Android 5 and forcing an iOS 15.5 floor is defensible on security grounds. The real test is whether WhatsApp makes the exit path painless or just points to the store.
Bitchat's French surge is a trust signal, not a security guarantee
Downloads spiked in France before the October 24 protests, though no shutdown is planned. Offline Bluetooth chat is useful, but its range and unproven security deserve caution.
