iPhone
Mobilsfera Newsroom
iPhone

Apple's French trial shows parts pairing is a choice, not a law of nature

A Paris court will judge whether tying iPhone parts to serial numbers was engineering or obstruction. Regulators are right to treat it as a business decision, not a technical inevitability.

Published
November 17, 2026
Reading time
4 min
Categories
iPhone

Photo: Cullen Steber / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Is a phone that refuses a genuine camera a security feature or a sales strategy? A Paris court will have to decide, and it's about time someone put the question to a judge.

Paris is putting a software lock on trial

According to 01net, Paris prosecutors decided to take Apple to the criminal court over planned obsolescence through obstruction of repair. The case follows a complaint filed in December 2022 by the group HOP. It targets 24 iPhone models sold between November 17, 2021 and July 23, 2024. A preliminary hearing is set for February 25, 2027, and arguments should begin on June 17, 2027, over four days.

The core of the case is serialization, also called pairing: components such as the screen, battery or cameras are linked to the phone's serial number. HOP alleges that Face ID could stop working after a front camera swap and that battery health could disappear, even with a genuine part, if Apple hadn't approved the repair. Apple firmly contests the allegations, calling them unfounded, and says the best repair is the one you never need. No one has been convicted of anything.

Pairing is a design decision, and designs can be judged

Apple's defense isn't silly. As Numerama explains, Face ID talks to the chip's secure enclave, parts need calibration, and since iOS 18 pairing also flags components from phones locked by Activation Lock, which makes stripping stolen iPhones less profitable. Those are real concerns.

But a real reason for checking a part is not a reason for punishing it. Detecting an unknown component is one thing. Switching off features on a genuine, identical part until Apple blesses the repair, which is what HOP alleges, would be another. The first is security, and in our view the second would be a business model. Both run on the same serial number, which is why the "it's just engineering" defense is too convenient.

The French law cuts through this by asking about purpose. Numerama notes that the text targets techniques that aim to block repair outside approved channels, so the court must establish intent, not just a constraint. We think that's the right test. Intent can be argued, documented and rebutted. A black box of "the software decides" can't.

The numbers explain why this matters

HOP says Apple charges 489 euros for a screen replacement on the latest iPhones, against an average of 161 euros in France according to the eco-organization Ecosystem. Numerama adds that Apple's own parts cost nearly as much as an Apple Store repair, which charges 405 euros for an out-of-warranty iPhone 18 Pro screen. And every repair must still be validated online by Apple.

Those figures don't prove intent, and the two sources don't line up neatly. They do show what's at stake: whoever controls validation controls the price of the repair. Apple's program for independent shops requires certification and a contract that not every repairer can or wants to sign. In our view, that leaves many shops choosing between Apple's terms and a second-class result.

Apple has already moved, and that cuts both ways

Apple has launched self-service repair, allowed used genuine parts, and made some repairs verifiable from the phone itself. HOP acknowledges this but says it still needs to be confirmed over time. We read it two ways. It's progress. It also suggests the restrictions were negotiable all along, which weakens the claim that they were technically unavoidable. A lock that can be loosened was never physics.

The trial matters more than the fine

Don't expect a quick revolution. The planned obsolescence offense has been in French law for more than ten years and, per 01net, it has never led to a conviction. As for the penalty, Le Matin, relaying AFP, reports a fine of up to 300,000 euros, possibly a percentage of annual revenue, while HOP puts the risk at up to 5% of revenue. The court will have the last word.

Either way, the trial matters more than its penalty. It treats a software setting as something a manufacturer chose and must justify. If you're buying an iPhone, favor models and shops where parts swaps keep full functionality, and ask repairers whether the job will be validated. For regulators, this is the right fight: not banning anti-theft checks, but forcing companies to prove that each restriction protects the user rather than the repair counter.

Debate topics

No topics yet: start the first one.

More stories