450,000 folds sounds great, but the iPhone Duo's hinge test isn't the proof it seems
CNET's machine says the iPhone Duo's hinge suffers but doesn't break. Fine, but dust, creases and cracked screens are the real questions, and Apple should publish its own numbers.
AI-generated image
Can a machine that opens and closes a phone for three weeks tell you whether the foldable in your pocket will last? Only partly, and the headlines about the iPhone Duo's hinge "suffering but not breaking" are a good reason to be precise about which part.
What the machine actually showed
CNET has been folding the Duo nonstop since October 23. According to MacRumors, after more than 451,000 folds the hinge shows wear. CNET says it started feeling looser around 390,000 folds. Another report, from iPhoneAddict, says the effect got worse from 440,300 cycles, when the screen no longer fully reached its open position before the machine started the next closing. The phone still works.
That is a good result. Earlier, BGR calculated that 300,000 folds at 50 a day is about 16.4 years. We think that framing is the problem. A hinge that outlasts the phone's useful life is nice to know, but it answers a question few buyers were asking.
Hinge fatigue is not what worries buyers
What did worry buyers was the Crackgate. As Clubic recounts, days after launch, photos appeared of inner screens cracked along the hinge on phones that had never been dropped. Apple acknowledged a problem affecting "a small number" of units and offered replacements, with no cause and no figure. The most serious lead, Clubic says, is a batch of faulty parts from a hinge supplier, but nothing is confirmed.
That matters for reading the CNET result. One unit surviving 450,000 folds says the design can be robust. It says nothing about whether the batch you buy is the good one. A test of one device can't catch a supplier defect, and a single sample is a single sample.
The machine also leaves out almost everything that kills phones. BGR itself notes that drops, bumps, pressure and dust all take their toll, which makes a lone fold count potentially misleading. Dust is the clearest gap. Numerama points out that the Duo is rated IP68 and protected against fine dust, while the Galaxy Z Fold 8 only has IP48, which covers particles larger than a millimeter. That is a real difference on paper, and no fold robot measures it.
Creases are another gap. One of the shorter early tests reported by Blog Nouvelles Technologies noted a more visible crease after 11,500 cycles, though that is a snippet and we can't judge its method. So the screen's aging deserves as much attention as the hinge's.
Apple should put its own number on the table
Apple has declined to share how many folds the Duo's hinge endured in its own testing. BGR suggests the company may see little value in a single figure, and we partly agree: a number alone is easy to game. But silence is worse. Rivals publish figures: BGR cites Samsung at 200,000 folds for the Fold 8, Motorola at 400,000 for the Razr Ultra (2026), and Oppo with TÜV Rheinland certification for 1 million cycles on the Find N6. Those numbers are marketing, yes, but they can be checked and argued over.
The Duo costs 2,339 € in 256 GB, according to Clubic and Numerama, against 1,119 € for a Fold 8 after Samsung's offer. At that premium, "trust us" doesn't cut it. We'd ask Apple for three things: the fold count and test conditions, a dust and debris protocol, and a clear statement of what the Crackgate was and how many units it affected.
Our verdict
If you're considering a Duo, the CNET test is genuinely reassuring about the hinge mechanism, and we'd take it as good news for the used market too. Don't take it as a warranty. Inspect the crease and the hinge area the moment you unbox it, as Clubic advises, and keep your proof of purchase. The robot answered the easy question. Apple still owes us the hard ones.
No topics yet: start the first one.
More stories
The iPhone Duo's hinge isn't the flaw. Apple's silence is
A reported 30% return rate and a hinge showing wear after 400,000 folds mark the Duo as a first-gen product. Apple should publish durability data, not just swap units.
iPhone 18 Pro Max won the battery test, but don't buy it for that
CNET's 32-phone shootout crowned Apple again, yet its method says more about software tuning than about how your own day will go.
Apple's hidden keyboard blacklist should be public, and editable by you
A secret list of words your iPhone won't suggest or swipe is editorial power in disguise. Apple should publish it and let you override it.
Crackgate isn't about cracks: it may be about Apple rushing its first foldable
A Foxconn worker says Apple eased inspections on the iPhone Duo before the holidays. Unproven, but it fits the evidence, and it's reason enough to wait before paying 2,339 euros.



